TL;DR: Aetna, a CVS Health company, modified CPB 0247 covering autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) for knee cartilage defects, effective January 18, 2026. Here's what billing teams need to do.
This update to the Aetna autologous chondrocyte implantation coverage policy tightens the medical necessity criteria your team needs to document before billing CPT 27412 or submitting HCPCS J7330 for MACI implants. The policy governs a procedure with high per-claim dollar exposure — MACI (Vericel) isn't cheap, and a claim denial on a missing documentation element is a painful write-off. Know the 13 required criteria before the claim leaves your practice.
Quick-Reference Table
| Field | Detail |
|---|---|
| Payer | Aetna, a CVS Health company |
| Policy | Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation — CPB 0247 |
| Policy Code | CPB 0247 |
| Change Type | Modified |
| Effective Date | January 18, 2026 |
| Impact Level | High |
| Specialties Affected | Orthopedic Surgery, Sports Medicine, Orthopedic Billing |
| Key Action | Audit all ACI prior authorization requests against the full 13-criteria checklist before submitting to Aetna |
Aetna Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation Coverage Criteria and Medical Necessity Requirements 2026
The Aetna autologous chondrocyte implantation coverage policy under CPB 0247 Aetna system sets a high bar. Every single one of 13 criteria must be met for Aetna to consider the procedure medically necessary. Miss one, and the claim gets denied — or the prior authorization never clears.
Here are the 13 required criteria for CPT 27412 and HCPCS J7330 to be covered:
| # | Covered Indication |
|---|---|
| 1 | Age: 15 or older with documented growth plate closure, or an adult under 55 |
| 2 | BMI: 35 or below at time of request |
| 3 | Patient cooperation: Documented ability and willingness to follow post-op weight bearing and activity restrictions, plus a realistic potential to complete rehab |
| 4 | Failed conservative therapy: Minimum six weeks of physical therapy within the past year |
| 5 | Defect grade: Full-thickness focal chondral defect down to but not through subchondral bone (grade IV) on a load-bearing surface — medial femoral condyle, lateral femoral condyle, trochlea, or patella |
| 6 | Opposing surface: Modified Outerbridge grade 0 or 1 on the opposing articular surface |
| 7 | Informed consent: Documented with realistic expectations |
| 8 | No active arthritis: No active inflammatory or other arthritis, confirmed clinically and by X-ray |
| 9 | Nicotine-free: No nicotine use — including tobacco and nicotine replacement therapy — for at least six weeks before surgery. For anyone with nicotine use within the past year, Aetna requires a lab report (not a surgeon summary) showing blood or urine nicotine levels ≤10 ng/ml or urinary cotinine ≤10 ng/ml, drawn within six weeks before surgery |
| 10 | Disabling symptoms: Documented disabling pain and/or knee locking that limits activities of daily living |
| 11 | Not for osteoarthritis: The procedure cannot be done to treat degenerative arthritis |
| 12 | Defect size: 2–4 sq cm for arthroscopic cases (CPT 29870, HCPCS S2112); 2–8 sq cm for open surgical cases (CPT 27412) |
| 13 | Stable, aligned knee: Intact meniscus and normal joint space on X-ray; corrective procedures may be required first to restore stability and alignment |
The nicotine criterion is the one that trips up the most authorizations. A surgeon's note saying the patient "reports not smoking" doesn't satisfy this requirement. Aetna wants a lab value, from a qualified lab, drawn within the six-week window. Build that into your pre-auth workflow now.
Aetna treats FDA-approved matrix-induced chondrocyte implantation — specifically MACI (Vericel), billed under HCPCS J7330 — as an equally acceptable alternative to the original autologous cultured chondrocytes (Carticel). Carticel was pulled from the U.S. market in 2017 and replaced by MACI, so if you still have Carticel in your charge master, remove it. MACI and HCPCS J7330 are your billing path here.
Prior authorization is effectively required given the clinical complexity and cost of ACI. Confirm your Aetna contract's PA requirements, but don't submit without every documentation element above.
Aetna Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation Exclusions and Non-Covered Indications
This is where autologous chondrocyte implantation billing gets complicated. Aetna considers several related procedures experimental, investigational, or unproven — and that designation means no reimbursement.
ACI is not covered for:
| # | Excluded Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | Ankle (talar) lesions or lesions of the hip, shoulder, or any joint other than the knee |
| 2 | Patients who have had a previous total meniscectomy |
| 3 | Cartilage defects associated with osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, or inflammatory diseases — or where an osteoarthritic or inflammatory process significantly degrades peri-lesional cartilage quality |
| 4 | Patients with known anaphylaxis to gentamicin or sensitivities to materials of bovine origin |
| 5 | Use as an initial or first-line surgical therapy (conservative treatment must fail first) |
Separate procedures also considered experimental:
| # | Excluded Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | Autologous matrix-induced chondrogenesis (AMIC) for articular cartilage defects of the talus, patellofemoral lesions, or other osteochondral defects |
| 2 | Autologous platelet-rich plasma and fibrin-augmented minced cartilage implantation for chondral defects |
The exclusion on first-line surgical therapy connects directly to the conservative care criterion above. If your patient hasn't completed at least six weeks of physical therapy in the past year, Aetna will deny this as non-medically necessary — not just inappropriate sequencing. Document that PT failure explicitly in the authorization request.
The total meniscectomy exclusion is worth flagging at scheduling. If a patient has had a prior total meniscectomy, don't put them through the PA process. This is a hard stop under the current coverage policy.
CPT codes 20900, 20902 (bone grafts), and 29868 (meniscal transplantation) are not covered for the indications listed in CPB 0247. Don't bundle these onto an ACI claim expecting coverage.
Coverage Indications at a Glance
| Indication | Status | Relevant Codes | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grade IV focal chondral defect, knee, femoral condyle or patella — all 13 criteria met | Covered | CPT 27412, J7330, S2112, 29870 | Prior auth recommended; nicotine lab required for recent users |
| MACI (Vericel) as alternative to Carticel | Covered | J7330 | Carticel no longer marketed in U.S. since 2017 |
| Arthroscopic harvest of cartilage cells | Covered | S2112 | Covered when meeting selection criteria |
| ACI for ankle (talar) or other joints (hip, shoulder) | Experimental | — | Insufficient evidence of safety/effectiveness |
| ACI in patients with prior total meniscectomy | Experimental | — | Hard exclusion |
| ACI for osteoarthritis or inflammatory joint disease | Experimental | — | Not covered; separate OA exclusion also applies |
| ACI as first-line surgical therapy | Experimental | — | Conservative therapy must fail first |
| AMIC for talus, patellofemoral, or other osteochondral defects | Experimental | — | Insufficient evidence |
| PRP/fibrin-augmented minced cartilage implantation | Experimental | — | Insufficient evidence |
| Bone grafts (minor or major) for ACI indications | Not Covered | CPT 20900, 20902 | Not covered for CPB 0247 indications |
| Meniscal transplantation | Not Covered | CPT 29868 | Not covered for CPB 0247 indications |
Aetna Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation Billing Guidelines and Action Items 2026
This policy was modified January 18, 2026. If your team hasn't updated your ACI authorization workflow since then, do it now.
| # | Action Item |
|---|---|
| 1 | Audit your prior authorization checklist against all 13 criteria. Print the list. Make it a required sign-off before any ACI case is scheduled. Any criterion that isn't documented in the chart is a denial waiting to happen. |
| 2 | Update your nicotine documentation protocol immediately. For any patient with nicotine use in the past year, order a blood or urine nicotine lab (or cotinine) drawn within six weeks of the planned surgery date. The result must be ≤10 ng/ml. A surgeon attestation does not satisfy this requirement under CPB 0247. |
| 3 | Confirm MACI billing under HCPCS J7330. Remove any Carticel-specific line items from your charge master. MACI (Vericel) is the only FDA-approved chondrocyte implant currently on the market, and J7330 is your HCPCS code. Bill the implantation procedure under CPT 27412. |
| 4 | Flag total meniscectomy history at intake. Build a screening question into your orthopedic intake process. Patients with a prior total meniscectomy are categorically excluded from ACI coverage. Catching this before scheduling saves everyone time. |
| 5 | Document defect size in the operative report — specifically in sq cm. Aetna's policy requires 2–4 sq cm for arthroscopic cases and 2–8 sq cm for open cases. A vague "large chondral defect" won't hold up in a claim review. The arthroscopic harvest (HCPCS S2112) must tie to a qualifying defect size. |
| 6 | Verify the opposing articular surface is documented. Modified Outerbridge grade 0 or 1 is required on the opposing surface. This needs to be in the operative or diagnostic report — not inferred. Aetna reviewers look for this specifically. |
| 7 | Don't bill CPT 20900, 20902, or 29868 expecting coverage under CPB 0247. These codes are listed as not covered for the indications in this policy. If bone grafting or meniscal transplantation is also performed, those claims need separate clinical justification and will likely not clear under this CPB. |
If your practice has complex cases — patients near the age cutoffs, borderline BMI, or prior surgical history — loop in your compliance officer before the effective date for those cases. The denial exposure on a single ACI case is significant.
| Previous Version | Current Version |
|---|---|
| Coverage is considered experimental and investigational for all indications | Coverage is considered medically necessary when specific criteria are met |
| Prior authorization is not required | Prior authorization is required for initial treatment |
| Documentation must include clinical history | Documentation must include clinical history |
| Re-review every 24 months | Re-review every 12 months with updated clinical documentation |
CPT, HCPCS, and ICD-10 Codes for Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation Under CPB 0247
Covered CPT and HCPCS Codes (When Selection Criteria Are Met)
| Code | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
| 27412 | CPT | Autologous chondrocyte implantation, knee |
| 29870 | CPT | Arthroscopy, knee, diagnostic; with or without synovial biopsy (separate procedure) |
| J7330 | HCPCS | Autologous cultured chondrocytes, implant |
| S2112 | HCPCS | Arthroscopy, knee, surgical, for harvesting of cartilage (chondrocyte cells) |
Not Covered CPT Codes for CPB 0247 Indications
| Code | Type | Description | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20900 | CPT | Bone graft, any donor area; minor or small (e.g., dowel or button) | Not covered for indications listed in CPB 0247 |
| 20902 | CPT | Bone graft, any donor area; major or large | Not covered for indications listed in CPB 0247 |
| 29868 | CPT | Arthroscopy, knee, surgical; meniscal transplantation (includes arthrotomy for meniscal insertion) | Not covered for indications listed in CPB 0247 |
Key ICD-10-CM Diagnosis Codes
| Code | Description |
|---|---|
| M17.0–M17.9 | Osteoarthritis of knee (various laterality and type) |
| M22.2x1–M22.2x9 | Patellofemoral disorders (patellofemoral lesions) |
| M23.0 | Internal derangement of knee |
| M23.10–M23.19 | Internal derangement of knee, unspecified |
| M23.20–M23.29 | Internal derangement of knee, derangement of meniscus due to old tear or injury |
| M23.241–M23.249 | Derangement of anterior horn of lateral meniscus due to old tear or injury |
| M23.251–M23.259 | Derangement of posterior horn of lateral meniscus due to old tear or injury |
| M23.261–M23.269 | Derangement of other lateral meniscus due to old tear or injury |
| M23.30–M23.9 | Other internal derangements of knee |
| M00.00–M02.9 | Infectious arthropathies |
| M05.00–M19.93 | Inflammatory polyarthropathies and osteoarthritis |
The full ICD-10 list under CPB 0247 includes 254 codes. Review the complete code set at the official Aetna CPB 0247 source before coding.
Get the Full Picture for CPT 27412
Track this policy across versions, search 1,500+ policies by CPT code, and get real-time alerts when any payer changes coverage.